Price per sqft
Low
High
  1. Real Estate
  2. United States
  3. New York

  4. Most popular

      All

      1. Most popular

          All

          Luxury Homes for Sale in Shelter Island, New York, United States

          75 listings
          Sort:
          Premium
          1 / 30
          View 30 photos
          House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States 1
          $2,950,000
          5 Beds 5 Baths 4200 sqft
          House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
          Contact
          Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
          1 / 15
          View 15 photos
          House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States 1
          $2,100,000
          6 Beds 5 Baths 4389 sqft
          House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
          Contact
          Corcoran Shelter Island
          Theresa R. Andrew
          Theresa R. Andrew photo
          1 / 33
          View 33 photos
          $2,485,000
          4 Beds 3 Baths 2418 sqft
          House in Shelter Island, New York, United States
          Contact
          Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
          VALUATION $5.9M $5.6 - $6.3

          Know Your Property's True Worth

          Get an instant estimate backed by luxury transactions across 140+ countries.

          Get valuation
          1 / 12
          View 12 photos
          $3,499,000
          4 Beds 4 Baths 3856 sqft
          House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
          Contact
          Greater Nassau, NY
          1 / 26
          View 26 photos
          $3,200,000
          5 Beds 4 Baths 4254 sqft
          House in Shelter Island, New York, United States
          Contact
          1 / 26
          View 26 photos
          $4,295,000
          6 Beds 6 Baths
          House in Shelter Island, New York, United States
          Contact
          1 / 18
          View 18 photos
          $499,000
          1 Beds 1 Baths
          House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
          Contact
          1 / 3
          View 3 photos
          $575,000
          Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
          Contact
          Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
          New price
          1 / 16
          View 16 photos
          $3,750,000
          6 Beds 5 Baths 4884 sqft
          House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
          Contact
          1 / 28
          View 28 photos
          $3,850,000
          4 Beds 5 Baths 3985 sqft
          House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
          Contact
          New 4 hours ago
          1 / 40
          View 40 photos
          $4,250,000
          4 Beds 6 Baths 3500 sqft
          House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
          Contact
          Corcoran North Fork
          Sheri Winter
          Sheri Winter photo
          1 / 28
          View 28 photos
          $3,850,000
          4 Beds 6 Baths 3985 sqft
          House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
          Contact
          1 / 48
          View 48 photos
          $3,999,000
          4 Beds 7 Baths 5500 sqft
          House in Shelter Island, New York, United States
          Contact
          1 / 18
          View 18 photos
          $2,895,000
          Land in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
          Contact
          Corcoran East Hampton
          Gary DePersia
          Gary DePersia photo
          New price
          1 / 43
          View 43 photos
          $3,975,000
          4 Beds 5 Baths 3187 sqft
          House in Shelter Island, New York, United States
          Contact
          SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATES - BRIDGEHAMPTON
          Penelope Moore
          Penelope Moore photo
          1 / 35
          View 35 photos
          $2,349,000
          3 Beds 3 Baths 3312 sqft
          House in Shelter Island, New York, United States
          Contact
          SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATES - BRIDGEHAMPTON
          Penelope Moore
          Penelope Moore photo
          1 / 14
          View 14 photos
          $1,545,000
          2 Beds 3 Baths 1488 sqft
          Farm Ranch in Shelter Island, New York, United States
          Contact
          SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATES - BRIDGEHAMPTON
          Penelope Moore
          Penelope Moore photo
          New price
          1 / 23
          View 23 photos
          $1,250,000
          4 Beds 3 Baths 1235 sqft
          Farm Ranch in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
          Contact
          SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATES - BRIDGEHAMPTON
          Penelope Moore
          Penelope Moore photo
          1 / 22
          View 22 photos
          $1,950,000
          5 Beds 3 Baths
          House in Shelter Island, New York, United States
          Contact
          Video
          1 / 29
          View 29 photos
          $1,875,000
          3 Beds 4 Baths 3373 sqft
          House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
          Contact
          SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATES - BRIDGEHAMPTON
          Penelope Moore
          Penelope Moore photo
          1 / 50
          View 50 photos
          $22,000,000
          7 Beds 7 Baths 10000 sqft
          House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
          Contact
          Corcoran Shelter Island
          Seth P. Madore
          Seth P. Madore photo
          1 / 27
          View 27 photos
          $1,850,000
          4 Beds 2 Baths 2007 sqft
          House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
          Contact
          SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATES - BRIDGEHAMPTON
          Penelope Moore
          Penelope Moore photo
          1 / 17
          View 17 photos
          $4,000,000
          3 Beds 3 Baths 1626 sqft
          Farm Ranch in Shelter Island, New York, United States
          Contact
          1 / 23
          View 23 photos
          $1,845,000
          4 Beds 3 Baths 2296 sqft
          House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
          Contact
          Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
          1 / 4
          View 4 photos
          $750,000
          Land in Shelter Island, New York, United States
          Contact
          Corcoran Shelter Island
          Karen Springer
          Karen Springer photo
          1 / 4
          View 4 photos
          $775,000
          Land in Shelter Island, New York, United States
          Contact
          Corcoran Shelter Island
          Karen Springer
          Karen Springer photo
          1 / 4
          View 4 photos
          $775,000
          Land in Shelter Island, New York, United States
          Contact
          Corcoran Shelter Island
          Karen Springer
          Karen Springer photo
          1 / 4
          View 4 photos
          $750,000
          Land in Shelter Island, New York, United States
          Contact
          Corcoran Shelter Island
          Karen Springer
          Karen Springer photo
          1 / 27
          View 27 photos
          $1,649,000
          3 Beds 2 Baths 1502 sqft
          House in Shelter Island, New York, United States
          Contact
          Corcoran Shelter Island
          Jon Westervelt
          Video
          1 / 50
          View 50 photos
          $7,950,000
          3 Beds 4 Baths 4133 sqft
          House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
          Contact
          SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATES - BRIDGEHAMPTON
          Penelope Moore
          Penelope Moore photo
          Video
          1 / 50
          View 50 photos
          $10,750,000
          6 Beds 7 Baths 4200 sqft
          House in Shelter Island, New York, United States
          Contact
          Corcoran Shelter Island
          Rebecca Shafer
          Rebecca Shafer photo
          1 / 43
          View 43 photos
          $1,450,000
          4 Beds 4 Baths 1702 sqft
          House in Shelter Island, New York, United States
          Contact
          Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
          Next

          Start phone call with:

          Hello, I’m calling for the property with the reference , which I discovered on JamesEdition.

          After the call, we'll provide your contacts to the agent for easy communication.

          Homes for sale nearby Shelter Island, NY, United States

          Shelter Island, NY, United States property types

          Shelter Island, NY, United States popular searches

          Find real estate agencies in Shelter Island, New York

          Luxury Homes for Sale in Shelter Island, New York, United States - FAQ

          • Homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY, United States have an average listing price of $2,895,000 and range in price between $499,000 and $22,000,000. The average price per square meter is $905/sqft.
          • The most expensive home for sale in Shelter Island, NY, United States is a 10,000 sqft house with a listing price of $19,031,144.
          • The largest home for sale in Shelter Island, NY, United States is a $19,031,144 house with a size of 10,000 sqft.
          brokerages we
          partnered with
          JAMESEDITION
          CATEGORIES
          CATALOG
          FOR BUSINESS
          MOBILE APP
          GET IT ON Google Play
          SETTINGS
          Copyright © 2026 JamesEdition B.V.®