$4,800,000

Single Family Residence in Shelter Island

  • 5 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • 3,325 Sqft
  • 1.13 Ac lot
  • Updated: November 18
  • 3
  • Source:
    OneKey MLS  MLS#1007669

About the Property

190 FEET OF PRIVATE WATERFRONT | PRIVATE BEACH | DEEP-WATER DOCK | UNOBSTRUCTED SUNSET VIEWS |

Some waterfront properties are simply irreplaceable. 90 Peconic Avenue is one of them.

Set on a beautifully landscaped, level acre in Shelter Island’s coveted Silver Beach community, this exceptional property offers 190 feet of fully bulkheaded waterfront, a private beach, deep-water do
190 FEET OF PRIVATE WATERFRONT | PRIVATE BEACH | DEEP-WATER DOCK | UNOBSTRUCTED SUNSET VIEWS |

Some waterfront properties are simply irreplaceable. 90 Peconic Avenue is one of them.

Set on a beautifully landscaped, level acre in Shelter Island’s coveted Silver Beach community, this exceptional property offers 190 feet of fully bulkheaded waterfront, a private beach, deep-water dock, and sweeping western views with spectacular sunsets.

Custom built in 1985 by Reich Eklund, the classic Shingle-style residence offers approximately 3,325 square feet, five bedrooms, and 3.5 bathrooms. An open floor plan embraces the waterfront setting with water views from nearly every room, generous living spaces, two en-suite bedrooms—one on each level—an expansive waterside deck, and a full upper-level balcony. Central AC throughout with 2 cozy fireplaces, one wood burning, one gas. An oversized two-car garage and full basement complete the home.

An expansive, level side lawn offers exceptional potential for future enhancements, with architectural renderings illustrating a possible swimming pool, subject to approvals.

Held by the same family for nearly a century, this extraordinary waterfront parcel presents a rare opportunity to enjoy, reimagine, or enhance a remarkable Shelter Island estate.

190 feet of private shoreline. Your own beach and dock. Unobstructed sunsets. One exceptional opportunity.
…
  • Property type

    House

  • Year built

    1985

  • Price/sqft

    $1,443

Features

  • Fireplace
  • Garden
  • Garage
  • Waterfront
  • Beachfront
  • Open Kitchen
  • Balcony
  • Basement
  • Privacy

Explore the Area

90 Peconic Avenue, Shelter Island, New York, United States View on Google Maps
Price per sqft
Low
High

View 64 more listings in Shelter Island

Serhant East End LLC - Bridgehampton

Joined 10 months ago
Your message
You have inquired about this property

The agent will contact you soon by

Listed by

Serhant East End LLC - Bridgehampton
New York, United States
View agency profile
18
Listings
2026
Joined

Book home tour with the agent

Choose a date and whether you'd like a virtual or in-person tour with the agent.

In-person tour
Preferred date
Tour type
Serhant East End LLC - Bridgehampton
Bridgehampton, New York, United States
View agency profile
Last updated
November 18
First listed
June 2
Listing reference
1007669
Listing status
Call

Start phone call with:

Hello, I’m calling for the property with the reference 1007669, which I discovered on JamesEdition.

After the call, we'll provide your contacts to the agent for easy communication.

Brokerages we
partnered with