Price per sqft
Low
High
  1. Real Estate
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Shelter Island

  5. Most popular

      All

      Luxury Hilltop Homes for Sale in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States

      2 listings
      Sort:
      Premium
      New 6 days ago
      1 / 42
      View 42 photos
      House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States 1
      $3,750,000
      5 Beds 4 Baths 5386 sqft
      House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
      Contact
      1 / 15
      View 15 photos
      House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States 1
      $2,100,000
      6 Beds 5 Baths 4389 sqft
      House in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
      Contact
      Corcoran Shelter Island
      Theresa R. Andrew
      Theresa R. Andrew photo
      VALUATION $5.9M $5.6 - $6.3

      Know Your Property's True Worth

      Get an instant estimate backed by luxury transactions across 140+ countries.

      Get valuation

      That’s all homes matching your search

      Remove some of the filters to see more homes

      Or create an alert and be notified when homes like this appear

      Nearby homes
      1 / 14
      View 14 photos
      $1,545,000
      2 Beds 3 Baths 1488 sqft
      Farm Ranch in Shelter Island, New York, United States
      Contact
      SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATES - BRIDGEHAMPTON
      Penelope Moore
      Penelope Moore photo
      1 / 30
      View 30 photos
      $2,199,000
      5 Beds 4 Baths 2646 sqft
      Shelter Island, New York, United States
      Contact
      1 / 40
      View 40 photos
      $4,800,000
      5 Beds 4 Baths
      House in Shelter Island, New York, United States
      Contact
      1 / 26
      View 26 photos
      $3,200,000
      5 Beds 4 Baths 4254 sqft
      House in Shelter Island, New York, United States
      Contact
      1 / 33
      View 33 photos
      $2,485,000
      4 Beds 3 Baths 2418 sqft
      House in Shelter Island, New York, United States
      Contact
      Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
      1 / 35
      View 35 photos
      $2,349,000
      3 Beds 3 Baths 3312 sqft
      House in Shelter Island, New York, United States
      Contact
      SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATES - BRIDGEHAMPTON
      Penelope Moore
      Penelope Moore photo
      1 / 43
      View 43 photos
      $1,450,000
      4 Beds 4 Baths 1702 sqft
      House in Shelter Island, New York, United States
      Contact
      Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
      New price
      1 / 43
      View 43 photos
      $3,975,000
      4 Beds 5 Baths 3187 sqft
      House in Shelter Island, New York, United States
      Contact
      SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATES - BRIDGEHAMPTON
      Penelope Moore
      Penelope Moore photo
      New 4 days ago
      1 / 29
      View 29 photos
      $2,150,000
      4 Beds 3 Baths 2500 sqft
      House in Shelter Island, New York, United States
      Contact
      Corcoran Shelter Island
      Theresa R. Andrew
      Theresa R. Andrew photo
      1 / 26
      View 26 photos
      $3,600,000
      4 Beds 3 Baths 3210 sqft
      House in Shelter Island, New York, United States
      Contact
      Corcoran Shelter Island
      Susan Cronin
      Susan Cronin photo

      Start phone call with:

      Hello, I’m calling for the property with the reference , which I discovered on JamesEdition.

      After the call, we'll provide your contacts to the agent for easy communication.

      Homes for sale nearby Shelter Island Heights, NY, United States

      Shelter Island Heights, NY, United States property types

      Shelter Island Heights, NY, United States popular searches

      Find real estate agencies in Shelter Island Heights, New York
      brokerages we
      partnered with
      JAMESEDITION
      CATEGORIES
      CATALOG
      FOR BUSINESS
      MOBILE APP
      GET IT ON Google Play
      SETTINGS
      Copyright © 2026 JamesEdition B.V.®