Rare 2 Acre Hither Hills Compound Opportunity

A truly exceptional and exceedingly rare opportunity to acquire two contiguous properties in Montauk’s coveted Hither Hills community, creating a remarkable 2.03± acre compound with convenient access to Hither Hills ocean beach. Ideally positioned south of the highway and just moments from Montauk Village, this unique offering combines privacy, scale, and future development potential in one of the area’s most sought-after locations. Approached by a scenic and idyllic drive that captures the timeless charm and laid-back character of Old Montauk, the setting feels remarkably peaceful and secluded while remaining close to the area’s renowned beaches, restaurants, shops, marinas, and surf culture. Surrounded by natural coastal beauty, the offering includes a character-rich 2-bedroom, 1-bath beach cottage that can serve as an inviting retreat, guest house, or comfortable residence while future plans are realized. Together, the two parcels provide an extraordinary opportunity to create a significant coastal compound with a combined allowable gross floor area of approximately 11,908.2 square feet. Whether envisioned as a sprawling estate, a thoughtfully designed family retreat, or a legacy property to be enjoyed for generations, the combined acreage offers exceptional flexibility and scale rarely found in Hither Hills. There is ample room for pools, pool houses, outdoor entertaining areas, and recreational amenities, while a carefully designed second story may capture ocean views. Future owners will enjoy effortless access to a pristine stretch of Atlantic coastline, with miles of ocean beach just moments from their doorstep. Opportunities to assemble parcels of this size and quality in Hither Hills have become increasingly scarce. Offering an unmatched combination of acreage, location, privacy, and development potential, this is a rare chance to create a one-of-a-kind estate that embodies the very essence of Montauk living.