$3,495,000

Single Family Residence In Alexandria

  • 9 Beds
  • 5 Baths
  • 4,680 Sqft
  • 1.8 Ac lot
  • Updated: June 28
  • 10
    Views for last 30 days
  • Source:
    Central New York Information Services (CNYREIS)  MLS#S1688278

About the Property

Built in 1883 at the height of America’s Gilded Age, Comfort Island is one of the Thousand Islands’ most distinguished private estates. Commissioned by a prominent Chicago industrialist during the era when America’s great fortunes created legendary summer residences along the St. Lawrence River, the estate represents a rare opportunity to own not simply a home, but an enduring piece of North Ameri
Built in 1883 at the height of America’s Gilded Age, Comfort Island is one of the Thousand Islands’ most distinguished private estates. Commissioned by a prominent Chicago industrialist during the era when America’s great fortunes created legendary summer residences along the St. Lawrence River, the estate represents a rare opportunity to own not simply a home, but an enduring piece of North American history.
Occupying approximately 1.8 private acres, 9 bedrooms, 4.5 baths, the island has been painstakingly transformed through an extraordinary eight-year restoration. Every surface was carefully renewed while preserving the craftsmanship and character that define the estate’s nineteenth-century origins. Behind its historic walls lies an entirely modern residence, featuring new plumbing, electrical systems, HVAC, insulation, and mechanical infrastructure, allowing today’s owners to enjoy the elegance of the Gilded Age with every contemporary convenience.
Surrounded by the sparkling waters of the St. Lawrence River, the estate feels worlds away, yet the mainland marina is only three minutes away by boat, placing restaurants, boutiques, golf, marinas, and everyday conveniences within effortless reach.
The estate extends well beyond the main residence. A collection of beautifully restored historic outbuildings creates intimate destinations throughout the property—spaces for entertaining family and friends, quiet reflection, creative pursuits, or simply enjoying the rhythm of river life. Expansive dockage and a classic boathouse provide exceptional accommodations for both residents and visiting guests, making arrivals by water as gracious as they were more than a century ago.
Whether hosting an elegant summer dinner on the porch, gathering generations of family for celebrations, or enjoying a peaceful morning overlooking passing yachts and freighters, every corner of the property has been designed to embrace both grand entertaining and private retreat. This is truly a rare offering.
  • Property type

    House

  • Floors

    3

  • Year built

    1890

  • Price/sqft

    $746

Features

Explore the Area

45436 Comfort Islnd, Alexandria Bay, New York, United States View on Google Maps
Price per sqft
Low
High

View 10 more listings in Alexandria Bay

Garlock Realty - Alexandria Bay

Joined 6 months ago
Your message
You have inquired about this property

The agent will contact you soon by

Listed by

Garlock Realty - Alexandria Bay
New York, United States
View agency profile
14
Listings
2026
Joined

Book home tour with the agent

Choose a date and whether you'd like a virtual or in-person tour with the agent.

In-person tour
Preferred date
Tour type
Garlock Realty - Alexandria Bay
Alexandria Bay, New York, United States
View agency profile
Last updated
June 28
First listed
Jun 27
Listing reference
S1688278
Listing status
Call

Start phone call with:

Hello, I’m calling for the property with the reference S1688278, which I discovered on JamesEdition.

After the call, we'll provide your contacts to the agent for easy communication.

brokerages we
partnered with