272 Main Street, Sag Harbor, New York 11963

A landmark 1890 residence on Sag Harbor’s coveted Captains Row, this exceptional property represents a rare marriage of historic provenance, thoughtful restoration, and sophisticated design. Lovingly restored with great respect for its original architecture, the home retains its period details and timeless character while offering the comfort and refinement of a complete modern renovation. The restoration was thoughtfully conceived by architect Anthony Vermandois, known for his expertise in historic residential preservation and renovation, and executed by renowned builder Tom O’Donahue, with the grounds and gardens designed by celebrated landscape designer Charlie Marder. The owner, herself a well-known designer, personally selected every element of the home, resulting in interiors that feel collected, considered, and entirely individual. The four-bedroom residence features beautifully proportioned, light-filled rooms, including gracious living and sitting rooms, an inviting dining room, and a beautifully appointed kitchen. The primary suite opens to a private balcony overlooking the grounds, while three additional guest bedrooms provide comfortable accommodations for family and guests. Outside, Marder’s mature landscaping creates a remarkably private village oasis surrounding the heated gunite pool. A separate pool house with a full bath and outdoor shower completes the property. Rich in history and meticulously restored, this landmark Captains Row residence offers a rare opportunity to own a distinctive piece of Sag Harbor Village history-just moments from Main Street, the harbor, shops, and restaurants.